Meticulous tactical analysis of Antietam’s opening hours on September 17, 1862, reveals brutal command breakdowns.
Crisis at Antietam: The Cornfield and West Woods, September 17, 1862, provides a meticulous tactical analysis of the opening brutal hours of the Civil War’s bloodiest single day. Set within the broader Maryland Campaign, this groundbreaking work plunges readers into the chaos of September 17, 1862. The Confederate Army of Northern Virginia under Robert E. Lee was in grave peril. With nearly half his forces exhausted and straggling, Lee confronted George McClellan’s Army of the Potomac—a Union force poised for a decisive victory that famously slipped from its grasp.
Eden’s in-depth study of the fighting on the Confederate left uncovers critical missed opportunities, profound command failures, and the unpredictable hand of sheer chance. The fighting that raged through the Miller Cornfield and West Woods quickly spiraled beyond command control. Officers often failed to restore order amid the maelstrom; regiments and brigades acted independently, pushing forward without orders or full awareness of the battle’s unfolding horror. Union forces drove the Confederate front to the precipice of collapse on three occasions, only for the Rebels to miraculously rally each time, stabilizing their fragile lines against overwhelming odds.
Eden draws on extensive original sources, including memoirs, official reports, and soldier letters, together with his own invaluable combat experience as a retired Army officer and former West Point military history instructor. His insights are fresh and authoritative. Crisis at Antietam challenges even seasoned readers to fundamentally reconsider the traditional narrative of that pivotal bloody September day by exposing the raw, brutal reality of command and combat at Antietam.
Steven Eden is a retired Army officer and veteran of Afghanistan. He taught history at West Point and is the author of two books, including Military Blunders: Wartime Fiascoes from the Roman Age Through World War I, and numerous magazine articles for professional and historical journals. He specialized in conducting battlefield staff rides for military organizations in Europe and the United States, including Antietam, while an instructor at Fort Meade, Maryland. He currently resides within easy distance of the battlefield in Manchester, Maryland, with his wife Kathleen.
“Steve Eden’s Crisis at Antietam does a fine job of not only sorting out the confused combat during the bloodiest fighting of the climactic Battle of Antietam but describes in detail why it was so chaotic. This well written and thoughtfully analyzed study is a welcome addition to the literature of this important 1862 battle.”
~Thomas G. Clemens, editor of Ezra Carman’s The Maryland Campaign of 1862, Vols. 1–3
“Steven Eden paints a vivid picture of the opening phases of the Battle of Antietam. Using a variety of sources, he explains why the fighting was initiated at the Cornfield and the West Woods, what happened there, and the impact on the remainder of the battle. The book is well written and illustrated.”
~Bradley M. Gottfried, author of The Maps of Gettysburg
“In Crisis at Antietam, Steven Eden takes his trained military eye to the northern sector of the Antietam battlefield—the famed East Woods, West Woods, and Miller’s Cornfield. He dissects the morning’s battle on September 17, 1862, north of Sharpsburg, from the perspective of McClellan, Lee, and the countless other commanders who led their troops into battle on that bloody morning, while putting readers in the ranks with the common soldier. Eden’s analysis is both thorough and thoughtful.”
~Kevin R. Pawlak, co-author of To Hazard All: A Guide to the Maryland Campaign, 1862