Exploring sixteen historic leadership failures, this work analyzes how flawed decision-making at critical moments yields catastrophic results and distills practical lessons for making sound judgments under pressure.
Lieutenant General Foley was commissioned in the U.S. Army as an Airborne Ranger Infantry lieutenant and rose through the ranks to become commanding general of Fifth U.S. Army. During his career he received an MBA, graduating cum laude from Fairleigh-Dickinson University, was appointed commandant of cadets at West Point, became president of a military junior college, received the Infantry Doughboy Award and was named a Distinguished Graduate of the U.S. Military Academy.
In his command assignments, he realized that not only the decisions they make, but the words leaders speak, the actions they take, and the orders they give, are profoundly consequential as they directly impact people’s lives. He resolutely acknowledges that soldiers are a military’s most precious asset. He also believes that soldiers who trust their commanders won’t waver in the face of difficult tasks and will exhibit an indomitable spirit inspired by the respect they have for their leaders and the camaraderie they have with their fellow soldiers.
In Consequences of Command, General Foley pinpoints leadership failures in 16 case studies spanning two centuries. He identifies what and how these occurred and what could have been done differently. Each case concludes with a comprehensive list of lessons that summarize tenets, principles, and traits essential to leadership at crucial times.
Building upon these examples, General Foley discusses the necessity for leaders to frequently get out of their headquarters and visit soldiers, and emphasizes the need for leaders to be tough enough to enforce organizational values, standards and policies, ensure that everyone is treated with dignity and respect, and sustain the positive command climate essential for success.
Author’s Note Introduction
1 Napoléon 2 Fredericksburg 3 Vicksburg 4 Pandemic 5 “Billy” Mitchell and Air Power 6 B-29 over Nagasaki 7 Task Force Smith 8 Rifle Company Commander in Vietnam 9 USS Pueblo 10 Mỹ Lai Massacre 11 Desert One 12 Challenger Spacecraft 13 Mogadishu 14 Submarine Emergency Surface 15 Black Hearts 16 Combat Outpost Keating
Afterword Acknowledgements Endnotes Bibliography Index
Lieutenant General Robert F. Foley graduated from the U.S. Military Academy in 1963. He served as an infantry company commander during the War in Vietnam, a mechanized infantry battalion and armor brigade commander with the 3rd Infantry Division in Germany, assistant division commander, 2nd Infantry Division in Korea, deputy commanding general of Second U.S. Army, commanding general, U.S. Army Military District of Washington and commanding general Fifth U.S. Army. His awards include the Medal of Honor, two Distinguished Service Medals, six Legions of Merit and the Purple Heart. General Foley and his wife, Julie, reside in Alexandria, VA, and have two sons, a daughter and seven grandchildren.
"Consequences of Command is an extraordinary analysis of leadership, and no one could write like Lieutenant General Robert F. Foley. From intense, small unit combat in Vietnam to the operational complications of high command, Bob Foley has seen it all. In 16 incisive discussions of military failures throughout history, he distills the essential lessons of warfare. His insights range broadly, from the need for national readiness at all times to the character of leadership which is a critical aspect of every battle. This should be required reading for our leaders, both military and civilian."
~Senator Jack Reed, senior U.S. senator from Rhode Island and ranking member of the Senate Armed Services Committee
"Finally, a book on leadership that is powerful and impactful. Bob Foley’s book is consequential and relevant for leaders today. Incredible extraction of leadership lessons from historical examples—a must-read!"
~General Thomas A. Schwartz, U.S. Army Retired, former commander
"After a lifetime of serving alongside soldiers and leaders, I have learned that the true measure of leadership is found in the difficult decisions—when character, courage, and sound judgement matter most. In Consequences of Command, Lieutenant General Foley captures that truth with rare clarity and honesty, and this book should be required reading for anyone entrusted with the privilege and responsibility of leading others."
~Command Sergeant Major Charles E. Durr, Jr., U.S. Army Retired, former director of assistance operations, Army emergency relief and former command sergeant major, Installation Management Command, Atlantic Region
"For leaders at every level, moral courage combined with a ‘lessons learned’ mindset are success fundamentals. General Bob Foley has not only reminded us of the consequences if leaders forget these truths; he has also reinforced his overarching theme with highly relevant, even moving, historical examples that are essential reading for anyone entrusted with the lives of others."
~Lieutenant General Daniel W. Christman, U.S. Army Retired, former superintendent of the U.S. Military Academy and former senior vice president for International Affairs, U.S. Chamber of Commerce
"A magnificent must-read treatise about leadership. Congressional Medal of Honor recipient and Lieutenant General Foley provides valuable lessons for anyone entrusted with significant responsibility. Readers of all persuasions and leaders of military, civilian, political, and business organizations will find there is much to consume in this insightful examination of leadership, decision-making, and moral character and accountability."
~Lieutenant General Billy K. Solomon, U.S. Army Retired, former commanding general, U.S. Army Combined Arms Support Command
"General Foley, a renowned soldier, adroitly provides concise history and personal, sometimes provocative, commentary. The ‘Lessons Learned’ sections are a primer for all echelons of leadership. This book needs a place on your reading list."
~General David A. Bramlett, U.S. Army Retired, former commanding general, U.S. Army Forces Command and former deputy commander-in-chief and chief of staff, U.S. Pacific Command
"Bob Foley has written a superb analysis of past leadership failures. Some are well known and others are not. Military leaders and leaders of all organizations where human lives are at risk should read the book."
~Lieutenant General James T. Scott, U.S. Army Retired, former commanding general, US. Army Special Operations Command and former commanding general, 2nd Infantry Division
"An essential manual for modern military leaders. General Foley provides a course on moral strength and the consequences on what happens when it is absent—brilliantly proving true moral courage requires an uncommon, unshakeable kind of bravery."
~Lieutenant General Walter E. Piatt, U.S. Army Retired, CEO of Wounded Warrior Project and former commanding general, 10th Mountain Division
In today’s complex world there is a critical need for competent leadership. Having been thrust into myriad leadership situations, Bob Foley capitalizes on his successful career in the U.S. Army and his profound knowledge to analyze several leadership situations of the past to provide thought- provoking leadership considerations for future contingencies. Today’s leaders will be well served to read and understand Consequences of Command by a proven leader of consequence
~Major General William M. Boice, U.S. Army Retired, former commanding general, 1st Armored Division and president, West Point Class of 1963
"Bob Foley and I were ‘table mates’ at the Command and General Staff College where I quickly learned that he was an unusually passionate soldier. Thus, it was no surprise when I learned that he had invested a tremendous amount of time and effort developing and compiling case studies of leadership failures that can be highly important in future leadership studies and training in our military institutions."
~Lieutenant General Hubert G. Smith, U.S. Army Retired, former deputy commander-in-chief and chief of staff, U.S. Transportation Command
"These 16 examples are well-written, compelling narratives. I was most struck by General Foley’s consistent theme that we learn much more from our failures than we do from our successes. Studying failures causes leaders to question policies, assess change, and make improvements. Studying successes only encourages us to continue the status quo."
~Frank Lennon, author, publisher, and columnist, president, Rhode Island Aviation Hall of Fame, state military history advisor to the adjutant general, Rhode Island National Guard
"Written by a Congressional Medal of Honor recipient who has been in the fray, this is truly a compelling read on historical military leadership, with lesson applicable to leaders in any field. Lieutenant General Foley skillfully weaves together historical vignettes with both positive and negative examples of leadership, producing an excellent guide for aspiring young leaders everywhere."
~Dr. John E. (Eddie) Atwood, Colonel, U.S. Army Retired, professor of medicine, USU director of Cardiology Ambulatory and CCU Sub-internship, Walter Reed National Military Medical Center
"In Consequences of Command, this Medal of Honor recipient draws powerful lessons from historic leadership failures, reminding us that sound judgement, moral courage, and accountability matter most when the stakes are highest. Essential reading for leaders at every level."
~Lieutenant General Michael S. Linnington, U.S. Army Retired, former president and CEO of the USO and former CEO of the Wounded Warrior Project
"This is a superb study of leadership under very difficult circumstances. The author explains what happened during a variety of military operations that sometimes succeeded despite the lack of sufficient direction and support. Thanks to Lieutenant General Foley, we can truly appreciate the great requirements of effective command."
~Brigadier General John W. Mountcastle, U.S. Army Retired, former chief of military history and commander, U.S. Army Center of Military History